Unofficial archive — problems, solutions & results © IMC, reproduced with permission.

IMC / 2001 / Problems / Day 1, P2

IMC 2001 · Day 1 · P2

medium

Let r,s,tr, s, t be positive integers which are pairwise relatively prime. If aa and bb are elements of a commutative multiplicative group with unity element ee, and ar=bs=(ab)t=ea^r = b^s = (ab)^t = e, prove that a=b=ea = b = e.

Does the same conclusion hold if aa and bb are elements of an arbitrary non-commutative group?

Solution (official)

1. There exist integers uu and vv such that us+vt=1us + vt = 1. Since ab=baab = ba, we obtain ab=(ab)us+vt=(ab)us((ab)t)v=(ab)use=(ab)us=aus(bs)u=ause=aus.ab = (ab)^{us + vt} = (ab)^{us} \left( (ab)^t \right)^v = (ab)^{us} e = (ab)^{us} = a^{us} (b^s)^u = a^{us} e = a^{us}. Therefore, br=ebr=arbr=(ab)r=ausr=(ar)us=eb^r = e b^r = a^r b^r = (ab)^r = a^{usr} = (a^r)^{us} = e. Since xr+ys=1xr + ys = 1 for suitable integers xx and yy, b=bxr+ys=(br)x(bs)y=e.b = b^{xr + ys} = (b^r)^x (b^s)^y = e. It follows similarly that a=ea = e as well.

2. This is not true. Let a=(123)a = (123) and b=(34567)b = (34567) be cycles of the permutation group S7S_7 of order 7. Then ab=(1234567)ab = (1234567) and a3=b5=(ab)7=ea^3 = b^5 = (ab)^7 = e.

How the field did

contestants scored
182
average (of 20)
13.39
solved (≥ 80%)
44.5%
near-0 (≤ 10%)
10.4%
discrimination
0.41

Score distribution (field cohort)

Computed on contestants with a meaningful total (field cohort); discrimination is the corrected item–total correlation.

Similar problems

IMC 2018 · Day 1 · P2mediumavg 4.5/10 · solved 40% · near-0 48% · disc 0.56
IMC 2009 · Day 2 · P9hardavg 2.2/10 · solved 21% · near-0 76% · disc 0.46
IMC 2012 · Day 1 · P3hardavg 2.5/10 · solved 17% · near-0 66% · disc 0.49
IMC 2021 · Day 2 · P6hardavg 2.3/10 · solved 17% · near-0 71% · disc 0.57