Unofficial archive — problems, solutions & results © IMC, reproduced with permission.

IMC / 2004 / Problems / Day 2, P10

IMC 2004 · Day 2 · P10

very hard
linear algebraworth 20 pts

For n1n \ge 1 let MM be an n×nn \times n complex matrix with distinct eigenvalues λ1,λ2,,λk\lambda_1, \lambda_2, \dots, \lambda_k, with multiplicities m1,m2,,mkm_1, m_2, \dots, m_k, respectively. Consider the linear operator LML_M defined by LM(X)=MX+XMTL_M(X) = MX + XM^T, for any complex n×nn \times n matrix XX. Find its eigenvalues and their multiplicities. (MTM^T denotes the transpose of MM; that is, if M=(mk,l)M = (m_{k,l}), then MT=(ml,k)M^T = (m_{l,k}).)

Solution (official)

We first solve the problem for the special case when the eigenvalues of MM are distinct and all sums λr+λs\lambda_r + \lambda_s are different. Let λr\lambda_r and λs\lambda_s be two eigenvalues of MM and vr\vec{v}_r, vs\vec{v}_s eigenvectors associated to them, i.e.\ Mvj=λvjM \vec{v}_j = \lambda \vec{v}_j for j=r,sj = r, s. We have Mvr(vs)T+vr(vs)TMT=(Mvr)(vs)T+vr(Mvs)T=λrvr(vs)T+λsvr(vs)TM \vec{v}_r (\vec{v}_s)^T + \vec{v}_r (\vec{v}_s)^T M^T = (M \vec{v}_r)(\vec{v}_s)^T + \vec{v}_r \bigl( M \vec{v}_s \bigr)^T = \lambda_r \vec{v}_r (\vec{v}_s)^T + \lambda_s \vec{v}_r (\vec{v}_s)^T, so vr(vs)\vec{v}_r (\vec{v}_s)

is an eigenmatrix of LML_M with the eigenvalue λr+λs\lambda_r + \lambda_s.

Notice that if λrλs\lambda_r \ne \lambda_s then vectors u,w\vec{u}, \vec{w} are linearly independent and matrices u(w)T\vec{u}(\vec{w})^T and w(u)T\vec{w}(\vec{u})^T are linearly independent, too. This implies that the eigenvalue λr+λs\lambda_r + \lambda_s is double if rsr \ne s.

The map LML_M maps n2n^2–dimensional linear space into itself, so it has at most n2n^2 eigenvalues. We already found n2n^2 eigenvalues, so there exists no more and the problem is solved for the special case.

In the general case, matrix MM is a limit of matrices M1,M2,M_1, M_2, \dots such that each of them belongs to the special case above. By the continuity of the eigenvalues we obtain that the eigenvalues of LML_M are

  • 2λr2 \lambda_r with multiplicity mr2m_r^2 (r=1,,kr = 1, \dots, k);
  • λr+λs\lambda_r + \lambda_s with multiplicity 2mrms2 m_r m_s (1r<sk1 \le r < s \le k).
(It can happen that the sums λr+λs\lambda_r + \lambda_s are not pairwise different; for those multiple values the multiplicities should be summed up.)

How the field did

contestants scored
176
average (of 20)
3.15
solved (≥ 80%)
5.7%
near-0 (≤ 10%)
75.0%
discrimination
0.52

Score distribution (field cohort)

Computed on contestants with a meaningful total (field cohort); discrimination is the corrected item–total correlation.

Similar problems

IMC 2001 · Day 2 · P10very hardavg 1.2/10 · solved 7% · near-0 75% · disc 0.44
IMC 2019 · Day 1 · P5killeravg 0.8/10 · solved 5% · near-0 91% · disc 0.35
IMC 2008 · Day 2 · P11very hardavg 0.8/10 · solved 7% · near-0 90% · disc 0.43
IMC 2001 · Day 1 · P5very hardavg 1.5/10 · solved 7% · near-0 74% · disc 0.48