Unofficial archive — problems, solutions & results © IMC, reproduced with permission.

IMC / 2015 / Problems / Day 1, P5

IMC 2015 · Day 1 · P5

very hard

Let n2n \ge 2, let A1,A2,,An+1A_1, A_2, \dots, A_{n+1} be n+1n + 1 points in the nn-dimensional Euclidean space, not lying on the same hyperplane, and let BB be a point strictly inside the convex hull of A1,A2,,An+1A_1, A_2, \dots, A_{n+1}. Prove that AiBAj>90\angle A_i B A_j > 90^\circ holds for at least nn pairs (i,j)(i, j) with 1i<jn+11 \le i < j \le n + 1.

(Proposed by Géza Kós, Eötvös University, Budapest)

Solution (official)

Let vi=BAiv_i = \overrightarrow{B A_i}. The condition AiBAj>90\angle A_i B A_j > 90^\circ is equivalent with vivj<0v_i \cdot v_j < 0. Since BB is an interior point of the simplex, there are some weights w1,,wn+1>0w_1, \dots, w_{n+1} > 0 with i=1n+1wivi=0\sum\limits_{i=1}^{n+1} w_i v_i = 0.

Let us build a graph on the vertices 1,,n+11, \dots, n+1. Let the vertices ii and jj be connected by an edge if vivj<0v_i \cdot v_j < 0. We show that this graph is connected. Since every connected graph on n+1n + 1 vertices has at least nn edges, this will prove the problem statement.

Suppose the contrary that the graph is not connected; then the vertices can be split in two disjoint nonempty sets, say VV and WW such that VW={1,2,,n+1}V \cup W = \{1, 2, \dots, n+1\}. Since there is no edge between the two vertex sets, we have vivj0v_i \cdot v_j \ge 0 for all iVi \in V and jWj \in W. Consider 0=(iVWwivi)2=(iVwivi)2+(iWwivi)2+2iVjWwiwj(vivj).0 = \left( \sum_{i \in V \cup W} w_i v_i \right)^2 = \left( \sum_{i \in V} w_i v_i \right)^2 + \left( \sum_{i \in W} w_i v_i \right)^2 + 2 \sum_{i \in V} \sum_{j \in W} w_i w_j (v_i \cdot v_j). Notice that all terms are nonnegative on the right-hand side. Moreover, iVwivi0\sum\limits_{i \in V} w_i v_i \ne 0 and iWwivi0\sum\limits_{i \in W} w_i v_i \ne 0, so there are at least two strictly nonzero terms, contradiction.

Remark 1. The number nn in the statement is sharp; if vn+1=(1,1,,1)v_{n+1} = (1, 1, \dots, 1) and vi=(0,,0i1,1,0,,0ni)v_i = (\underbrace{0, \dots, 0}_{i-1}, -1, \underbrace{0, \dots, 0}_{n-i}) for i=1,,ni = 1, \dots, n then vivj<0v_i \cdot v_j < 0 holds only when i=n+1i = n+1 or j=n+1j = n+1.

Remark 2. The origin of the problem is here: http://math.stackexchange.com/questions/476640/ n-simplex-in-an-intersection-of-n-balls/789390

How the field did

contestants scored
318
average (of 10)
1.13
solved (≥ 80%)
9.4%
near-0 (≤ 10%)
82.1%
discrimination
0.49

Score distribution (field cohort)

Computed on contestants with a meaningful total (field cohort); discrimination is the corrected item–total correlation.

Similar problems

IMC 2009 · Day 1 · P5killeravg 0.5/10 · solved 4% · near-0 92% · disc 0.28
IMC 2012 · Day 2 · P9very hardavg 1.9/10 · solved 10% · near-0 75% · disc 0.47
IMC 2007 · Day 2 · P11very hardavg 0.9/10 · solved 8% · near-0 89% · disc 0.55