Define the sequence a0,a1,… of numbers by the following
recurrence:
a0=1,a1=2,(n+3)an+2=(6n+9)an+1−nanfor n≥0.
Prove that all terms of this sequence are integers.
Proposed by Khakimboy Egamberganov, ICTP, Italy
Solution (official)
Hint: Determine the generating function ∑anxn.
Take the generating function of this sequence
f(x)=n=0∑∞anxn.
It is easy to see that the sequence is increasing and
anan+1=(n+2)an(6n+3)an−(n−1)an−1<n+26n+3⇒n→∞limsupanan+1≤6.
So the generating function converges in some neighbourhood of 0.
Then, we have
f(x)=1+2x+n=2∑∞anxn=1+2x+n=0∑∞an+2xn+2=1+2x+n=0∑∞n+36n+9an+1xn+2−n=0∑∞n+3nanxn+2.
Let
f1(x)=n=0∑∞n+36n+9an+1xn+2 and
f2(x)=n=0∑∞n+3nanxn+2. Then
(xf1(x))′=n=0∑∞(6n+9)an+1xn+2=6x2n=0∑∞(n+1)an+1xn+3xn=0∑∞an+1xn+1=6x2f′(x)+3x(f(x)−1)
and
(xf2(x))′=n=0∑∞nanxn+2=x2n=0∑∞(n+1)anxn−x2n=0∑∞anxn=x2(xf(x))′−x2f(x)=x3f′(x).
Using this relations,
we arrive at the following differential equation for f:
(xf(x))′=1+4x+(xf1(x))′−(xf2(x))′=1+x+(6x2−x3)f′(x)+3xf(x)
or, equivalently,
(x3−6x2+x)f′(x)+(1−3x)f(x)−1−x=0.
So, we need solve
this differential equation in some sufficiently smaller
neighbourhood of 0. We know that f(0)=1 and we need a
neighbourhood of 0 such that x2−6x+1>0. Then
f′(x)+x(x2−6x+1)1−3xf(x)=x(x2−6x+1)1+x
for x=0. So the integral multiplier is
μ(x)=x2−6x+1x and
(f(x)μ(x))′=(x2−6x+1)23x+x2,
so
f(x)=(2x2−6x+11−x−21)xx2−6x+1=2x1−x−x2−6x+1.
We found the generating function of (an) in some neighbourhood
of 0,
which
x2−6x+1>0. So our series uniformly converges to
f(x)=2x1−x−x2−6x+1 in
∣x∣<3−22.
Instead of computing the coefficients of the Taylor series of
f(x) directly, we will find another recurrence relation for
(an). It is easy to see that f(x) satisfies the quadratic
equation xt2−(1−x)t+1=0. So
xf(x)2−(1−x)f(x)+1=0.
Then
x(n=0∑∞anxn)2+1=n=0∑∞anxn−n=0∑∞anxn+1⇒n=0∑∞(k=0∑nakan−k)xn+1=n=0∑∞(an+1−an)xn+1
and from here, we get
an+1=an+k=0∑nakan−k.
If a0,a1,…,an be integers,
then an+1 is also integer. We know that a0=1,a1=2
are integer numbers, so all terms of the sequence (an) are
integers by induction.
How the field did
contestants scored
360
average (of 10)
0.38
solved (≥ 80%)
1.7%
near-0 (≤ 10%)
91.7%
discrimination
0.33
Score distribution (field cohort)
Computed on contestants with a meaningful total (field cohort); discrimination is the corrected item–total correlation.