Unofficial archive — problems, solutions & results © IMC, reproduced with permission.

IMC / 2013 / Problems / Day 2, P9

IMC 2013 · Day 2 · P9

Does there exist an infinite set MM consisting of positive integers such that for any a,bMa, b \in M, with a<ba < b, the sum a+ba + b is square-free?

(A positive integer is called square-free if no perfect square greater than 1 divides it.)

(Proposed by Fedor Petrov, St. Petersburg State University)

Solution (official)

The answer is yes. We construct an infinite sequence 1=n1<2=n2<n3<1 = n_1 < 2 = n_2 < n_3 < \dots so that ni+njn_i + n_j is square-free for all i<ji < j. Suppose that we already have some numbers n1<<nkn_1 < \dots < n_k (k2k \ge 2), which satisfy this condition and find a suitable number nk+1n_{k+1} to be the next element of the sequence.

We will choose nk+1n_{k+1} of the form nk+1=1+Mxn_{k+1} = 1 + Mx, with M=((n1++nk+2k)!)2M = ((n_1 + \dots + n_k + 2k)!)^2 and some positive integer xx. For i=1,2,,ki = 1, 2, \dots, k we have ni+nk+1=1+Mx+ni=(1+ni)min_i + n_{k+1} = 1 + Mx + n_i = (1 + n_i) m_i, where mim_i and MM are co-prime, so any perfect square dividing 1+Mx+ni1 + Mx + n_i is co-prime with MM.

In order to find a suitable xx, take a large NN and consider the values x=1,2,,Nx = 1, 2, \dots, N. If a value 1xN1 \le x \le N is not suitable, this means that there is an index 1ik1 \le i \le k and some prime pp such that p21+Mx+nip^2 \mid 1 + Mx + n_i. For p2kp \le 2k this is impossible because pMp \mid M. Moreover, we also have p21+Mx+ni<M(N+1)p^2 \le 1 + Mx + n_i < M(N+1), so 2k<p<M(N+1)2k < p < \sqrt{M(N+1)}.

For any fixed ii and pp, the values for xx for which p21+Mx+nip^2 \mid 1 + Mx + n_i form an arithmetic progression with difference p2p^2. Therefore, there are at most Np2+1\frac{N}{p^2} + 1 such values. In total, the number of unsuitable values xx is less than i=1k2k<p<M(N+1)(Np2+1)<k(Np>2k1p2+p<M(N+1)1)<<kNp>2k1(p1)p+kM(N+1)<N2+kM(N+1).\begin{align*} \sum_{i=1}^{k} \sum_{2k < p < \sqrt{M(N+1)}} \left( \frac{N}{p^2} + 1 \right) &< k \left( N \cdot \sum_{p > 2k} \frac{1}{p^2} + \sum_{p < \sqrt{M(N+1)}} 1 \right) < \\ &< k N \sum_{p > 2k} \frac{1}{(p-1) p} + k \sqrt{M(N+1)} < \frac{N}{2} + k \sqrt{M(N+1)}. \end{align*} If NN is big enough then this is less than NN, and there exist

a suitable choice for xx.

Similar problems