Show that the equation cos(cosx)=sin(sinx) has no real
solutions.
(proposed by Alexander Slávik, Charles University, Prague)
Solution (official)
Assume, for contradiction, that there exists x∈R such that
cos(cosx)=sin(sinx). Using
cost=sin(2π−t), we may rewrite this as
sin(2π−cosx)=sin(sinx).
Set
A=2π−cosxandB=sinx.
Since sinx,cosx∈[−1,1], we have
A∈[2π−1,2π+1]andB∈[−1,1].
The general solutions of sinA=sinB are
A−B=2kπorA+B=(2k+1)π,k∈Z.
The above bounds on A and B force k=0. Hence either
2π−cosx=sinx
or
2π−cosx=π−sinx.
After rearranging, these equations become, respectively,
sinx+cosx=2π
and
sinx−cosx=2π.
However,
sinx±cosx≤2,
as follows, for example, from
sinx±cosx=2sin(x±4π).
Since
2<2π,
neither equality is possible. Hence the equation
cos(cosx)=sin(sinx)
has no real solutions.
How the field did
contestants scored
412
average (of 10)
8.26
solved (≥ 80%)
72.8%
near-0 (≤ 10%)
6.1%
discrimination
0.11
Score distribution (field cohort)
Computed on contestants with a meaningful total (field cohort); discrimination is the corrected item–total correlation.